top of page
Writer's pictureNature Ready Outdoors

A Beginner's Guide of the Pros and Cons of Different Wilderness Shelters for the Mountains

Updated: Aug 5

When venturing into the mountains, knowing how to build a suitable shelter is crucial for your survival. Different shelter types have their own pros and cons, and understanding these can help you make an informed decision when you're in the wild. In this beginner's guide, we'll explore the advantages and disadvantages of various wilderness shelters and highlight common mistakes beginners make and how to avoid them. Be sure to check out the do's and don'ts quick reference guide.


Lean-To

Different Wilderness Shelters

1. Lean-To Shelter

Pros:

  • Easy to Construct: The lean-to is one of the simplest shelters to build, requiring minimal materials and tools.

  • Quick Setup: It can be set up quickly, making it ideal for emergency situations.

  • Good Ventilation: The open front provides good airflow, reducing condensation inside the shelter.

Cons:

  • Limited Protection: Offers less protection from the elements, especially wind and rain, due to its open design.

  • Heat Retention: Not very effective at retaining heat, making it less suitable for cold weather conditions.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them:

  • Mistake: Building the lean-to facing the wind.

  • Avoid This By: Positioning the open side away from prevailing winds to reduce exposure.


A-Frame Shelter

2. A-Frame Shelter

Pros:

  • Sturdy and Stable: The A-frame structure is highly stable and can withstand strong winds and heavy snow.

  • Good Insulation: Provides better insulation than a lean-to, making it suitable for colder environments.

  • Efficient Water Runoff: The sloped design allows rain and snow to slide off easily.

Cons:

  • More Time-Consuming: Requires more time and effort to build compared to simpler shelters.

  • Resource-Intensive: Needs more materials, which might be scarce in some areas.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them:

  • Mistake: Using weak branches for the frame.

  • Avoid This By: Selecting strong, sturdy branches for the main support structure to ensure stability.


Debris Shelter

3. Debris Hut

Pros:

  • Excellent Insulation: Packed with leaves and debris, it provides great insulation, keeping you warm in cold conditions.

  • Blends with Environment: Its natural materials help it blend into the surroundings, offering some level of camouflage.

Cons:

  • Time-Consuming: Building a debris hut takes considerable time and effort.

  • Requires Abundant Materials: Needs a large amount of leaves and debris, which may not be readily available.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them:

  • Mistake: Not using enough debris for insulation.

  • Avoid This By: Ensuring you gather and use a thick layer of debris to maximize insulation and warmth.


Tarp Shelters

4. Tarp Shelter

Pros:

  • Versatile and Lightweight: A tarp is easy to carry and can be set up in various configurations to suit different conditions.

  • Quick Setup: Can be erected quickly, making it ideal for emergency situations.

  • Waterproof: Provides excellent protection from rain when set up correctly.

Cons:

  • Limited Insulation: Offers minimal insulation, making it less effective in cold weather.

  • Vulnerability to Wind: Can be less stable in high winds if not secured properly.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them:

  • Mistake: Failing to secure the tarp adequately.

  • Avoid This By: Using strong anchors and taut lines to secure the tarp, ensuring it remains stable in windy conditions.


A Lesson Learned

On a solo trip, I decided to build a simple lean-to shelter, thinking it would be quick and easy. I had been bush waking all day and was worn out and ready to stop. At the time I thought I picked the best spot. It was on slightly elevated ground with plenty of nearby trees for support and branches for building.

I hurried gathered materials, for the frame and plenty of leafy boughs for covering. I had constructed a shelter that I thought was quite adequate for the night. I oriented the open side to face the stunning mountain view, thinking it would be nice to wake up to such a picturesque scene.

As night fell, the temperature dropped rapidly. I soon realized my mistake. The open side of the shelter was facing directly into the prevailing wind, which had picked up considerably as the night progressed. The cold wind swept into my shelter, making it nearly impossible to retain any warmth. I tried to adjust by adding more branches and leaves to the open side, but it was too late and too dark to make a significant difference.

I ended up spending a miserable night, shivering and awake, constantly adjusting my position to try and shield myself from the relentless wind. At one point, I even considered abandoning the shelter and finding a more protected spot, but I knew that wandering around in the dark could be even more dangerous.

The experience was a harsh lesson in the importance of proper shelter orientation and preparation. It also underscored the need to be adaptable and to think critically about shelter placement based on environmental factors, rather than the view.


Several Key Takeaways:

  • Always consider wind direction: Position your shelter’s entrance away from the wind.

  • Prepare for the unexpected: Weather conditions can change rapidly in the mountains.

  • Plan and test your shelter: Ensure your shelter is robust and can withstand the elements before nightfall.


Tepee Shelter

Do's and Don'ts Checklist

Do's:

  • Do choose the right shelter type for the conditions: Consider the weather, available materials, and your skill level.

  • Do gather adequate materials: Ensure you have enough resources to construct a sturdy and insulated shelter.

  • Do consider wind direction: Position your shelter to minimize exposure to prevailing winds.

  • Do secure your shelter properly: Use strong anchors and sturdy construction to withstand wind and rain.

  • Do allow for ventilation: Ensure your shelter has proper airflow to prevent condensation and maintain air quality.

Don'ts:

  • Don’t rush the construction: Take your time to build a solid and reliable shelter.

  • Don’t ignore insulation: Failing to insulate properly can lead to cold, uncomfortable nights.

  • Don’t overlook site selection: Choose a site that is safe from flooding, falling branches, and other hazards.

  • Don’t forget to check weather patterns: Adapt your shelter based on expected weather conditions.

  • Don’t assume one size fits all: Be prepared to adjust your shelter type based on specific needs and circumstances.


Conclusion

Choosing and building the right wilderness shelter is a critical skill for anyone venturing into the mountains. By understanding the pros and cons of different wilderness shelter types and learning from the mistakes of others, you can significantly improve your chances of staying safe and comfortable in the wild. Remember to plan ahead, adapt to your environment, and use the lessons from those more experienced to guide your decisions.

Comments


bottom of page